Mystic Stamp Company’s Approval Service Makes Collecting Easy!

At Mystic Stamp Company, stamp collecting is meant to be easy, enjoyable, and risk-free. That’s why we offer our famous Pick-And-Choose Approval Service – a simple way for stamp collectors like you to examine stamps from the comfort of home, with no pressure or obligation to buy.

Stamps Chosen Just for You

With Mystic’s unique approval service, you’ll discover a hand-picked selection of stamps, coins, First Day Covers, plate blocks — there are endless possibilities — all sent straight to your door. Each selection is chosen with care by our team of experts. They can help you find sought-after older issues, fill album spaces, and explore areas of collecting you might never have considered before.

Why Collectors Love Mystic’s Approval Service

Collectors have told us it’s fun to see the stamps in person before deciding to purchase them. It’s always exciting to see stamps in real life — to hold them, study their details, and appreciate their beauty up close before deciding which ones to keep. That hands-on experience is what makes collecting so enjoyable.

Mystic’s Approval Service is also a real time-saver for collectors. Instead of spending hours searching through dealers or online listings, Mystic does the work for you. Our experts hand-select stamps, covers, and other items that match your collecting interests and deliver them right to your door.

When you buy stamps this way, you are in control. Keep as many or as few stamps as you like. If something doesn’t fit your collection, just return it. Be sure to share your collecting interests with your Personal Stamp Advisor — they’ll hand-select items based on your feedback and preferences. This approach lets you enjoy the hobby your way — discovering stamps you love while staying in full control of what you receive and how much you spend.

And don’t forget: Mystic Stamp Company has been serving collectors for more than a century. We’ve earned a reputation for honesty, reliability, and a genuine passion for the hobby. Our experts draw on decades of experience to select quality stamps, covers, and collectibles for every Approval selection. Each order reflects the same care, accuracy, and respect for collectors that have made Mystic a trusted name in philately since 1923.

When We Say No Obligation or Pressure – We Mean It!

There’s never any obligation to buy any of the items you’ll enjoy browsing through on approval. But you’ll welcome the special low price you get if you do keep them all.

Think about it – you’re free to look over stamps in the comfort of your own home and pick-and-choose what you’d like to keep. You pay only for the stamps you select — no minimum purchase, no pressure, and no surprises.

Stamp Collecting—the World’s Greatest Hobby…

We urge you to take advantage of this remarkable service. Getting stamps on approval will open the door to a lifetime of rewards through stamp collecting that so many of our friends have enjoyed. Imagine what Mystic can do for you in the future as your collection grows.

Stamp collecting offers something for everyone — from the excitement of finding a long-sought issue to the quiet satisfaction of organizing and displaying your collection. It’s a wonderful way to learn about history, geography, and art while building something uniquely your own. Every stamp connects you to a story — and every collection reflects the person who builds it.

There’s a whole team of dedicated people here to serve your needs. And be sure to tell us all about your collection. That way, your own personal stamp advisor can select beautiful stamps that are most likely to appeal to you and most likely to add to the pleasure you take in your collection.

Don’t just take our word for it. Here’s what our customers tell us about building a collection with Mystic: