Mystic Stamp Services

We Encapsulate $100+ Stamps For You

When you buy a stamp from Mystic that’s $100 or more, it will come in archival-quality encapsulation – using the same material used by the Smithsonian National Postal Museum. With Mystic as your collecting partner, every stamp you purchase has been professionally authenticated by our stamp experts.  Their entire job is to carefully inspect the … Read more

Read More

Why Choose Mystic?

Hi – We’re Mystic and we’d like you to know a little more about us… Our mission is to bring the joy of stamp collecting to the world.  And over the years, it’s this goal that has helped us grow into America’s leading stamp dealer. For almost 100 years we’ve been helping people discover all … Read more

Read More

Identify Any Stamp in Your Collection for Only $3

Our new Stamp ID service offers fast identification of your stamps and covers for only $3 per item.

Read More

Did You Know Mystic Offers Flat-Rate Shipping and Guaranteed Delivery?

Getting your stamps and supplies is easy and affordable with Mystic’s convenient flat-rate shipping.

Read More

Mystic’s Shipping Information

Mystic sends most orders by the U.S. Postal Service, although we do use FedEx and UPS on occasion.  Shipments generally arrive in 7-10 days.

Read More

Most Frequently Asked Questions

Our Customer Service Representatives talk to hundreds of collectors each day.  Often, the callers have questions like these.

Read More

Mystic Buys Stamps

Mystic spent over $72 million on stamps in the past five years, yet our need for stamps is still at an all-time high.

Read More

Privacy Policy

Thank you for placing your trust in Mystic Stamp Company! We are committed to the security and privacy of your personal information.

Read More

Mystic’s Return Policy

You must be completely satisfied with any stamp or collecting supply you order from Mystic.  If not, simply return it to us within 90 days in its original packaging.

Read More

Love history?

Discover events in American history – plus the stamps that make them come alive.

Subscribe to get This Day in History stories straight to your inbox every day!