Why Choose Mystic?

Mystic is the Collector’s Trusted Friend

Over 100 Years of Experience

We have a large team focused on helping you with your hobby.

Authenticity is Guaranteed

Anything you buy from us is guaranteed to be accurately described and guaranteed.

We Support Stamp Collecting

We sponsor hundreds of members for the American Philatelic Society each year and donate materials to support the hobby.

What does a century of experience in the stamp world mean for you? 

After 100 years, taking care of collectors and spreading the joy of collecting is still what we’re all about. Every time you choose Mystic, here’s what you’ll get.  We know you’re going to love it.

Group of Mystic employees
Don Sundman with Mystic colleagues

The highest-quality stamps and supplies.

Mystic stands behind every stamp we sell –so you can be confident you’re receiving exactly the stamp quality you’ve paid for.  Our standards are the strictest in the stamp world because your satisfaction is our top priority.  Doing business with Mystic means you’ll avoid dealers with lower condition standards – those who may try to sell you a lower condition for more money to turn a quick profit.

Buying stamps your way.

Mystic lets you buy stamps in whatever way works best for you.  Know what you need?  Our website and catalog are simple and easy to use.  Want to inspect your stamps for up to 21 days before you pay?  Your Personal Stamp Advisor will send stamps you’re interested in to examine in the comfort of your home.  Looking to build a topical collection without spending time shopping?  Our stamp clubs send a new shipment of stamps to your mailbox each month, with no obligation to purchase.

90-day Money-Back Guarantee. 

Mystic works hard to make sure you get the quality stamps and supplies you deserve.  In the unlikely event you need to return an item or have it replaced, our 90-day hassle-free policy covers every stamp and supply you order from Mystic.

Industry-leading Customer Service.

dedicated, friendly, full-time, US-based Customer Service team handles all your questions.

A Personal Stamp Advisor

to help build the collection of your dreams. Need help finding a special stamp?  Not sure what to collect next?  Contact us and a Personal Stamp Advisor will give you advice – it’s free!

Helping the stamp-collecting hobby and community.

Your business allows Mystic to support our great hobby.  Whether it’s sponsoring new members to the American Philatelic Society, donating stamps to give young visitors at the National Postal Museum, or offering rewards for famous missing stamps, Mystic is constantly working to ensure the future of stamp collecting.

Supporting small-town America values.

Mystic is a 100% employee-owned company in the small town of Camden in upstate New York.  We employ 150 full- and part-time colleagues thanks to the loyalty of our valued customers.  And we always keep our small-town values at the forefront of our business.  We treat people the way we want to be treated.