Mystic’s Shipping & Return Policies

Our domestic shipping is a flat rate no matter how many items you add to your cart—just $3.50 per order. Whether you adding a few stamps to your collection, or treating yourself to our entire Hingeless Stamp Album, your shipping cost stays the same. This one low rate also includes guaranteed delivery, so you can shop with confidence.

We do have additional options if you wish to receive guaranteed tracking or expedited shipping:

Just select the option you want when checking out. Orders with expedited shipping placed by 1:30 p.m. Eastern will ship the same day; later orders will ship the next business day.

International Shipping

Mystic proudly ships to collectors around the world! International shipping costs are calculated at checkout based on your destination.

Note: We’re unable to ship to the following countries at this time: Afghanistan, Haiti, Iran, Lebanon, Libya, Russia, Sudan, South Sudan, Syria, Turkey, Ukraine, and Yemen.

No Double Shipping Charges

If part of your order is on backorder, don’t worry—you’ll only pay for shipping once. When the remaining items are ready, we’ll send them at no extra cost, using the same shipping method you selected for your original order.

Hassle-Free Returns

We want you to love your stamps. If you’re not completely satisfied, you can return your order within 90 days in its original packaging. We’ll gladly issue a credit voucher or refund, whichever you prefer.

For help with a return, contact our customer service team at 1-866-660-7147 or by email at mystic@mysticstamp.com.