About Mystic

Why should I shop with Mystic compared to others?
Our mission is to bring the joy of stamp collecting to the world.

Here’s how we do it:
- We’ve been around for over 100 years and we put that experience to work for you every day.
- We offer only the highest-quality stamps and supplies.
- We offer industry-leading customer service with a department full of stamp experts.
- Everything you buy from Mystic is backed by our 90-day money-back guarantee.
- We offer a FREE personal stamp advisor service.
- We have a generous Rewards Points program – you earn 10 Rewards Points for every dollar you spend at Mystic. You can use those points on a wide selection of stamps and collecting supplies.
Click here to learn more.
Why aren’t some stamp conditions or formats offered on your website?

Only conditions and formats currently available for sale are listed. If a condition or format is not listed, we do not have it at this time. For example, many 2023 used stamps are scarce and difficult to find. We only offer the 2023 used stamps we have in stock right now.
Do you offer a worldwide catalog?

We do not offer a worldwide catalog. The Scott Catalogue is an excellent resource for worldwide stamps. You may also be able to borrow them from your local library or you can purchase the catalog(s) you need on Amazon.com.
Can I use the stamps you sell to mail a letter or a package?

Most of our mint US postage stamps are valid for postage and can be used on mail in the United States.
I’m getting too much mail from Mystic. How do I reduce the amount?

We like to keep you up to date on all the latest and greatest offers Mystic has, but we understand that sometimes means getting a little more mail than you’d like. If that’s the case, simply e-mail mystic@mysticstamp.com and let us know you’d like to take a break from our mailing list at this time.
What are your hours?

Our customer service representatives are available to speak with you every Monday through Friday from 8:30 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. Eastern Standard Time. Simply call 1-800-433-7811.
Can I create a Mystic wish list?

Yes you can – watch the video below for more details.
Do you ship internationally?

Yes! If you have any questions about completing your international order you can e-mail us at mystic@mysticstamp.com.
Your offer mentions stamps “on approval.” What does that mean?

Mystic sends stamps “on approval” that we think our collectors might enjoy. It’s a small number of stamps for you to examine in your home without any obligation. After you receive the stamps, take up to 21 days to decide if you want to purchase some, all, or none. Return any stamps you don’t want along with your reply form in the postage-paid envelope we’ve provided (postage-paid envelope provided for introductory approval shipment only). Stamps on approval are risk free and it’s our way of helping you get one step closer to owning the collection of your dreams. If you have any further questions, simply email us at info@mysticstamp.com and we’ll be happy to help.