Group of Mystic employees

How Mystic Can Help Your Collection Grow

Located in Camden, New York, Mystic Stamp Company has been serving stamp collectors across America since 1923! President Donald Sundman and 150 dedicated stamp colleagues offer you many ways to enjoy your hobby.

1. FREE Mystic’s U.S. Stamp Catalog

A complete, fact-filled guide to help you make the most of your collection. Printed in color to show off our beautiful US postage stamps, it contains prices, fun and interesting facts about different stamps. Plus a list of all the latest supplies you need to enjoy your collection. Request your free catalog when placing an order, with your approval selection, or contact our Customer Service Department.

2. FREE At-Home Examination Service…

Mystic offers a “see-before-you-buy” service for collectors who wish to receive stamps “on approval.” Selections are mailed to your door; you may purchase all, part, or none of the selection, returning the items not purchased. And you have up to 21 days after receiving the stamps to make your decision!

3. Fast, Convenient Service

By using Mystic’s convenient mail order service, you get fast, personal service right to your mailbox – without the hassles of driving, parking, or lack of time. You always make up your own mind, and shop the hours YOU choose!

4. Guaranteed Satisfaction

All stamps and supplies ordered from Mystic are backed by a money-back guarantee of satisfaction. If you aren’t completely satisfied with any stamp or collecting supply ordered from Mystic, simply return it to us within 90 days. We will gladly issue you a credit voucher or refund your money, whichever you prefer.

5. Rewards Points

for each dollar you spend at Mystic, you receive 10 valuable Rewards Points. Save your Rewards and trade them for merchandise and supplies from our Rewards Points lists. It’s a special bonus that helps stretch your hobby dollars!

6. Customer Service

If you ever have a question, problem, or stamp need, you may write, call, e-mail, or fax Mystic’s Customer Service Department at:

Mystic Stamp Company
9700 Mill Street, Camden, NY 13316

To order toll-free call: 1 (800) 433-7811
Weekdays, 8:30 AM – 5:00 PM Eastern Time
Toll-free fax (Anytime): 1 (800) 385-4919
Order online at

Need help? You’ll get prompt, friendly service from Mystic, so if there’s anything we can do to help, please let us know. Thank you for choosing Mystic to help your hobby grow!

Share this Article