John Jay Becomes First Supreme Court Chief Justice

On October 19, 1789, John Jay was sworn in as the first chief justice of the Supreme Court of the United States, becoming the head of a new judicial branch that would help define the rule of law in the young country. Though the event was modest in ceremony, it marked the beginning of one of the most important institutions in American government.

John Jay was already one of America’s most accomplished Founding Fathers. Born in 1745 in New York City, he was educated at King’s College (now Columbia University) and quickly rose to prominence as a skilled lawyer and thoughtful statesman. Jay played a key role in the First and Second Continental Congresses, where he worked to defend colonial rights and later to help shape the new country. During the Revolutionary era, he helped draft New York’s first state constitution and served as the state’s chief justice of the Supreme Court of Judicature.

Jay’s abilities also earned him important diplomatic roles. He was appointed Ambassador to Spain in 1779, where he negotiated support for the American cause. Later, he joined Benjamin Franklin and John Adams in negotiating the Treaty of Paris (1783), the agreement that officially ended the American Revolution and secured recognition of the United States as an independent country.

After the war, Jay served as secretary of foreign affairs under the Articles of Confederation, essentially functioning as America’s top diplomat. He saw firsthand how weak the national government was under the Articles and became a strong advocate for a more unified, centralized federal system. His support for the new Constitution was unwavering, and he joined Alexander Hamilton and James Madison in writing the Federalist Papers—a series of essays arguing for the ratification of the US Constitution. Jay authored five of these essays, focusing on the importance of unity and the need for an independent judiciary to preserve justice and order.

When the Constitution was finally ratified in 1788, President George Washington faced the enormous task of building a government from scratch. Among his first responsibilities was appointing leaders to the major new offices. In September 1789, Washington offered Jay the post of secretary of state. Although the title was new, the position would have carried similar duties to those Jay already held as secretary of foreign affairs. Jay politely declined, perhaps seeking new challenges. Washington soon offered him another historic role—chief justice of the Supreme Court.

Washington described the position as “the keystone of our political fabric,” emphasizing how critical it would be to the country’s stability. Jay accepted, and on September 24, 1789, Washington officially nominated him. Two days later, the Senate unanimously confirmed him. On October 19, 1789, John Jay took the oath of office, becoming the first chief justice in US history.

In the early years, the Supreme Court’s work was very different from what we know today. For its first three years, much of the court’s time was spent creating rules, procedures, and traditions, as well as admitting lawyers to the bar and riding circuit—traveling around the country to preside over federal district court cases. Jay also used his time on the circuit to discuss constitutional ideas with local leaders and to strengthen public trust in the new federal government.

One of Jay’s most significant early actions came in 1790, when Treasury Secretary Alexander Hamilton asked the court to endorse legislation dealing with state debts. Jay firmly refused, stating that the Supreme Court could only decide actual cases brought before it—it could not issue political opinions or support legislation. This decision helped establish the independence of the judiciary, setting a crucial precedent that remains in place today.

During Jay’s six-year tenure as chief justice, the court heard only four major cases, but each helped define the scope of federal power and the balance between branches of government. In one case, the court ruled that the legislative and executive branches could not revise a judicial decision, reinforcing the separation of powers. In another, the justices declared that jurors had the authority to decide both questions of fact and law, clarifying the role of the jury system.

Perhaps the most notable case of Jay’s term involved whether a state—Georgia—could be sued by citizens of another state. The court ruled that it could, a decision that angered many states and led directly to the passage of the Eleventh Amendment, which limited such suits.

John Jay resigned from the Supreme Court in 1795 to become Governor of New York, continuing his lifelong service to the public. Yet his brief time as chief justice laid the foundation for the country’s highest court. By insisting on judicial independence, fairness, and constitutional boundaries, Jay helped define what justice would mean in the United States for centuries to come.

FREE printable This Day in History album pages Download a PDF of today’s article. Get a binder or other supplies to create your This Day in History album.

Discover what else happened on This Day in History.