Court Issues Ruling in the Amistad Case 

U.S. #1894 – The Supreme Court Building wasn’t completed until 1935.

On March 9, 1841, the U.S. Supreme Court issued its final ruling the case of United States v. Schooner Amistad.

In 1839, a group of Africans were kidnapped from Sierra Leone, taken aboard a boat, and forced into slavery. On the trip from Havana, Cuba, to Puerto Principe, Cuba, they rebelled and assumed control of the boat, the Amistad. They demanded the ship’s navigator take them back to Africa, but instead he tricked them and took them to the United States.

Upon reaching the U.S., Naval Lieutenant Thomas R. Gedney took who he believed to be slaves and the ship to Connecticut to claim salvage rights on the ship and all its contents. What followed was a lengthy court battle over who had the rights to the ship and everything on board, including the kidnapped Africans.

U.S. #811 from the Presidential Series.

A court case began which carried serious political consequences, both within the United States and internationally. The South was enraged as lower courts ruled that the Africans had been illegally kidnapped, as that had an impact on slaves in America. Spanish Queen Isabella II – not even a teenager yet – made wild demands upon U.S. President Martin Van Buren to return the Africans as Spanish property.

U.S. #4422d from the 2009 Supreme Court Justices issue.

Former President John Quincy Adams, a fervent abolitionist, jumped at the opportunity to defend kidnapped Africans. The U.S. government held that since they had mutinied and killed the crew, they should be deported. However, Adams argued that the Africans were illegally forced into the slave trade and had the legal right to do whatever necessary to ensure their freedom.

Adams argued that the numerous claims on the Africans were not relevant, as these were people (not property) and they were never slaves to begin with. Adams spoke for eight and a half hours, spiritedly defending their rights and discounting the claims of the opposition.

U.S. #4657 Poet Robert Hayden later wrote “Middle Passage” about the Amistad affair.

Many considered Adams fight to be an uphill battle. But in the end, the U.S. Supreme Court sided with Adams on March 9, 1841, with a 7-1 ruling in favor of the Africans. Associate Justice Joseph Story wrote in the opinion, “They are natives of Africa, and were kidnapped there, and were unlawfully transported.” It was a key statement that challenged the idea that slaves were property and not people. The Africans were freed and, with help of donations, returned home the following year.

The case proved influential in several successive U.S. laws and is considered by some to be the most important slavery related case prior to the Dred Scott decision.

Click here for more about the case.

Click here to see what else happened on This Day in History.

Did you like this article? Click here to rate:
4.9/5 - (7 votes)
Share this Article


    1. Obviously the statement of a racist and a bigot sihce there is nothing more than a claim by one person in the 20th century to “have seen letters” to support this. No letters exist, no one else ever saw them and it’s just another racist lie in an attenpt to discredit a man fighting for his lif e and who many consider to be a hero.

  1. This case proved once and for all that today’s African Americans were NOT descendants from slaves but were descendants of free men, women and children in Africa who were illegally kidnapped and forcibly brought to this country! During my last visit in Sierra Leone, I have met and interacted with the Mende people, one of the main ethnic groups in that country, a very intelligent and hard working folks.

  2. I’ve learned a lot with this lovely brief stories ……much more than some historical books

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *