Identify Any Stamp in Your Collection for Only $5
Have a stamp or cover in your collection you’ve always wondered about? Let the experts at Mystic take a look! Our new Stamp ID service offers fast identification of your…
All About Shipping & Returns
Shipping and guaranteed delivery is a flat rate of $3.50 per order regardless of item category or number of items. Shipments generally arrive in 7-10 days.
Mystic Buys Stamps
Mystic spent over $72 million on stamps in the past five years, yet our need for stamps is still at an all-time high.
Mystic’s Privacy Policy
Thank you for placing your trust in Mystic Stamp Company! We are committed to the security and privacy of your personal information.
Mystic’s Return Policy
You must be completely satisfied with any stamp or collecting supply you order from Mystic. If not, simply return it to us within 90 days in its original packaging.
Does Mystic Have a Store?
Sometimes people ask if Mystic has a store where they can buy stamps. While we don’t have a retail store, customers can stop by our facility to make a purchase.
Top Prices Paid for Rare Jenny Invert Stamps
Are you one of the lucky few to find a right-side-up Jenny Invert sheet?
Our Premium Hingeless American Heirloom Album
Finally – a hingeless stamp album that’s beautifully designed and affordable! The experts at Mystic spent years developing the Hingeless American Heirloom.
Let Mystic Help Your Collection Grow
Did you know Mystic offers a wide range of services that makes it fun and easy to enjoy your hobby time, whether you’re a new collector or a seasoned pro?